Ave Maria School of Law ยท 1L Class ยท Oct 21, 2026

LinkedIn + AI for Law Students.

Get found, get referred, then ace the interview - how hiring really works on the back end

Hello, Ave Law 1Ls! ๐Ÿ’™ You survived midterms, then jumped straight into the hot seat. Huge love to Allison, Sabrina and Aganze for raising their hands first, and to Allie, Kristen, Eileen, Becca, Dennis and everyone who kept the chat on fire.

And the biggest thanks to your Fantastic Five - Jill, Deanna, Celestine, Monica and Edward - for making this happen. Every prompt, tool and demo from today is below. ๐Ÿ‘‡

The big idea

Don't wait for offers to find you. Build your own luck.

When every 1L uses the same AI prompt, everyone starts to look the same. The edge goes to the people firms already know and trust.

Pop quiz #1

According to NALP, what share of summer 2026 2L offers came from on-campus interviewing (OCI)?

A) Just 20%. Jack was the lone voice in the chat - and he was right. "Small amount of job openings, lots of students." The other 80% came from employer-sponsored recruiting: direct applications, early outreach and relationships.

So this session wasn't about sitting back and waiting. It was about understanding how law firm recruiters think - and making it work for you.

Source: NALP, Perspectives on 2025 Law Student Recruiting (Jan 2026)

OCI / school
20%
Employer-led
80%

Tap any step to jump to the prompts, demos and answers from today.

1Get Found

Your LinkedIn is your digital calling card - for the rest of your career

Pop quiz #2

A recruiter searches for you online. What's the first thing they see: your GPA, your LinkedIn profile or your resume?

B) Your LinkedIn. As Jackson put it, it's the most publicly available thing about you. When Jeremy searched for the directors of NALP, the first result every single time was their LinkedIn profile.

And the recruiters use LinkedIn Recruiter - about $10,000 per seat per year, and every law firm pays for it, because all the world's talent is in one place.

1.3Bprofiles searched every time a recruiter searches
220characters in the headline that matters most
Job titleCan you do the job?
LocationAre you where I need you?
SkillsDo you have what it takes?

Allison's makeover, live

Goal: a summer position at a state attorney's office in Tampa.
The profile: great cover photo, great headshot, amazing school - but "state attorney" appeared nowhere.
The fix: "Aspiring State Attorney" - or "Seeking state attorney internships," "Exploring state attorney opportunities," or (Andrew's favorite) "Desirous of becoming a state attorney."
The gap: plenty of red on her skill check - yet she's already building legal research and legal writing as a 1L.
Her diagnosis: "Skills is something you can just write down. Experience is proof."
Her homework: get credit in her Experience section, in her own words. Then Jeremy's coming back for a full makeover.

๐Ÿท๏ธThe catch-22 of law school. You came here to change your career, but you haven't made the change yet. The prefix doesn't matter - your most important keyword in your most important section does. Recruiters don't have ESP, so lead them.
๐Ÿ•ต๏ธOpen to Work, stealth mode. Don't love the green badge? Pick Recruiters only - even recruiters at your own future firm can't see it. List up to five locations (Tampa, St. Petersburg, Orlando...) and a few roles. And recruiters say they don't care about the green badge anyway.
  1. Search LinkedIn for your target role like a recruiter would ("state attorney's office Tampa") and notice what every top profile has in its headline.
  2. Open a real job posting you're excited about - for this summer or three years from now.
  3. Paste it into your favorite AI tool and run Prompt 1.
  4. Save your own profile to PDF (three dots - or the Resources button - then Save to PDF) and run Prompt 2.
PROMPT 1Cut through the noise
What are the top 15 most important skill keywords for this job? What am I actually being graded on inside the LinkedIn Recruiter algorithm?

Job postings are your future boss calling out for skills. AI leaves you with just the signal.

PROMPT 2The LinkedIn Gauntlet
Which of those skills are missing from my profile? How would the LinkedIn Recruiter algorithm actually grade me overall and skill by skill?

Red today just means room to grow tomorrow.

๐ŸชคSkills is a trap. Applicant tracking systems weigh Experience far more than the Skills section, because experience is proof. Put criminal law, legal research and legal writing where you actually used them.
โš ๏ธTrust but verify. The chat's verdict. Allison's rule: if AI says you were filing court proceedings and you weren't, take it out. Walk into a state attorney's office with a resume full of lies - even AI's lies - and you'll be held accountable. You're the only world-class expert on your story.

Your questions, answered

Allie asked
Any tips for optimizing my About section?Write for two audiences. The algorithm just matches keywords, so feed it the ones that matter (in plain text or Top Skills). The human recruiter spends about five seconds scanning, so the first two sentences are everything: sentence one says where you're headed (state law, corporate law...), sentence two gives a stranger a reason to trust you.
Celeste asked
What voice should my About section be in?Skip the hoity-toity third person until you're a partner in the corner office. Recruiters are usually people-people, not lawyers, so first person and your human side is far more engaging.
Eileen asked
What if I'm still torn between different areas of law?Lead with that. No recruiter expects a 1L two months in to have it all figured out. Say what you're exploring - pro bono vs. big law, say - and why they should be excited about you either way. Your LinkedIn is a living, breathing document: update it as you get more focused.
Kristen asked
With so much delegated to AI, might the "recruiter" actually be an AI?The search algorithm is AI, but the law will be the last place human recruiters get replaced by androids. You're not just hiring a legal opinion - you're hiring someone accountable for your reputation. People will always want a human lawyer they can count on.
Becca asked
Do AI recruiting bots pass over people without much legal experience?There's no such thing as an AI bot recruiter in law. There are humans using algorithms to search. And no recruiter searches for "a generic lawyer" - they search for someone who fits one specific role. Build your profile around that role and you make them look like a hero.
Nina asked
Where's the better place for skills again?Your Experience section. The point isn't gaming the system - it's walking the talk. Show how you're using criminal law or legal analysis in school, not just a list stuffed at the bottom.
2Get Referred

Strangers get suspicion. Friends of friends get the benefit of the doubt.

Pop quiz #3

Which gives you a 10x advantage: applying online, applying on LinkedIn or getting referred?

C) Getting referred - nearly the whole chat nailed it. As Kristen said, it's someone vouching for you, which takes work off the recruiter's plate.

And that was 2016. With AI pushing the cost of one more online application to zero, the gap has grown: the referral advantage is now about 20x. The chasm has become a canyon.

Sources: Lever (2016) and Gem (2025) benchmarks, via UB Career Design Studio

10xreferral advantage in 2016
20xreferral advantage today

Sabrina's referral, live

The target: a tough-to-crack white-collar criminal defense firm in Boca Raton.
AI's pick: Sallah Astarita & Cox.
Who she knew there: nobody. Neither did Jeremy.
The insider: founding partner James Sallah, found on the firm's LinkedIn People tab (he went to "the wrong law school," but we won't hold it against him).
The warm path: a mutual connection, Amy, for a warm intro.
Jeremy's promise: a profile makeover - and if he knows someone inside Sallah or another firm, he'll go to bat for her.

๐Ÿ“ฌLinkedIn has tons of users, very little usage. A busy partner who last updated his profile 15 years ago isn't checking his LinkedIn inbox. He is checking email ten times a day. A warm intro breaks his "stranger danger" force field.
  1. Use Prompt 3 to find a dream firm that's tough to break into.
  2. Open the firm's LinkedIn page and click the People tab - it lists far more people than the firm's own website.
  3. Look for a mutual connection and ask them for a warm intro.
  4. No mutual? Use Prompt 4 to find the email format, then reach out where they actually look.
  5. In the chat, ask about their journey. Then ask the one last question below.
PROMPT 3Pick a tough target
Which is the firm with a [white-collar criminal defense] practice in [Boca Raton, Florida] that is the most competitive to break into?

AI is great at analyzing the labor market, not just your profile.

PROMPT 4Find their real inbox
What is the most common email format for employees at [Sallah Astarita & Cox]?

Go where busy people actually are.

Ask advice, not a job - the generativity questions

  1. "I'd love to learn about your journey. How did you go from [where you started] to [where you are]?"
  2. "What did you learn along the way?"
  3. "What should I be thinking about as I follow in your footsteps?"

Coming in with a resume pitch puts the force field right back up. Even super-successful partners want to share what they've learned - that's generativity.

The one last question - before they run to court
"If you were back in my shoes, trying to get started in [white-collar criminal defense], knowing what you know today, what would you be doing to get your best start?"

Ask for a referral, you get advice. Ask for advice, you get a referral. And of the roughly 1,000 students who've reached out to Jeremy since grad school, only about 50 ever followed up - so just staying in touch puts you in the top 5%.

3Ace the Interview

Can you do the job? Do I want to do it with you?

Pop quiz #4

Are you more likely to win a coin flip or get an offer from a callback interview?

A) The coin flip. As Tim did the math, a coin flip is 50-50 and a callback could have plenty of other candidates. NALP's latest numbers: just under half of callback interviews turned into offers. So the callback isn't a box-checking exercise - it's your last chance to stand out.

Source: NALP, Perspectives on 2025 Law Student Recruiting (Jan 2026)

50%coin flip
47%of callbacks became summer 2026 offers
Pop quiz #5

Who would you rather work with: Patrick, Mr. Krabs or Sandy?

Sandy - the room's clear winner. Eileen nailed why: dependable, gets the job done, and nice to everyone. Patrick is friendly but can't be trusted to deliver. Mr. Krabs is driven - but would you want 70-hour weeks with him?

Harvard Business School researchers find the same two things everywhere: competence and warmth. In law, where you'll spend 60, 70, 80 hours a week together, warmth matters even more.

Research: Cuddy, Kohut and Neffinger, "Connect, Then Lead," HBR

Aganze's interview prep, live

Goal: a JAG Corps summer position with the Marine Corps.
First move: do due diligence - talk to people who interviewed for the role before.
Then: let AI boil down the ocean into the 10 likeliest questions - a bevy of "tell me about a time" behavioral ones.
The framework: STAR, as Kristen and Tom called out.
The gym: a live Yoodli mock with a friendly interviewer and the classic "difficult teammate" question.
Jeremy's double offer: a profile makeover plus an interview makeover - share a Yoodli session and he'll give honest feedback.

๐Ÿ›๏ธBe the Odysseus of your own story. STAR isn't arbitrary - every great story follows it. A crew lost at sea (Situation), the challenge of getting home (Task), the Cyclops and the sirens (Action), the loving embrace of family (Result).
PROMPT 5Predict the questions
I'm interviewing for a [JAG Corps legal summer position]. What are the 10 most likely interview questions based on the exact things they're looking for and the exact things they want in a superior candidate?

AI translates from the world of hiring to the world of interviewing. Add the job description and any background you have.

PROMPT 6Build a STAR story
Generate a STAR story for number [2] based on my CV.

Based on your CV, so AI doesn't hallucinate. Then make it sound like you.

  1. Rehearse in front of other people - a mirror isn't good enough. Getting great takes practice and feedback.
  2. Book time with Deanna, Celestine, Jill and your career team for that feedback.
  3. The night before, get one last rep at Yoodli, the 24/7 AI interview gym that makes you warmer, not more robotic. Pick your role, branch and a friendly, blunt or rude interviewer.
๐Ÿ’กCharisma is a choice, not a gift. The words you use, how you listen, and whether you bring your stories to life or let them lie in the shadows.

Bonus answers from the last five minutes

Dennis asked
What's the question you wish we'd asked?How to get an edge beyond the obvious. Don't just find junior employees - find people hiring right now. Search LinkedIn for "I'm hiring" plus "attorney" or "paralegal," and you'll find future bosses posting for talent and not getting responses. Reach out and solve their problems.
Schwartz asked
Is a paid AI interview tool worth it, or is free enough?Your career team is your first line of practice. Yoodli's free sessions are plenty on top of that. Save your money for coffee chats with alumni - a way better investment.
A classmate asked
Is email the best way to apply?The best way is always a referral. So do both: apply early (applications in the first 96 hours after a posting fare far better than a week later), then immediately find insiders at that firm on LinkedIn. If your online application gets rejected and a partner says "this person is amazing," you're right back in.
Bryce asked
I don't see the three dots on my profile.LinkedIn rolls out changes one profile at a time - look for the Resources button instead. Same Save to PDF option.
Comic book cover: Jill Backer, Deanna Dodge, Celestine Oglesby, Monica Rengifo and Edward Neebling of Ave Maria School of Law as The Fantastic 5
For Jill, Deanna, Celestine, Monica and Edward, with love

Your Fantastic Five

Today Jill turned a whole class period over to your careers, Deanna ran the room (and fact-checked Jeremy's last name with AI - no hallucinations!), and Celestine, Monica and Edward have your back all year long.

So don't wait until callback season. Bring your new headline, your target firm and your STAR stories to their office now - that's the practice and feedback that turns a coin flip into an offer. Fides et ratio! ๐Ÿ’™

For you, with love

3 free gifts, Ave Law ๐ŸŽ

Courtesy of your Office of Professional Development. (Allison, Sabrina and Aganze: send me a message on LinkedIn and your makeovers are on me.)

Gift 1

Connect with me

A question you didn't want to ask in front of everyone, or one that hits you in the shower tomorrow? I'm the rare user who always checks his LinkedIn inbox.

Connect on LinkedIn
thejobinsiders.com/connect
Gift 2

A free profile makeover

Wanted a makeover but didn't win the hand-raising race? Here's your second bite at the apple, from a former LinkedIn insider.

Get your makeover
thejobinsiders.com/profile
ONE MORE THING โšก
Gift 3

ProfileBot 4K

Tell it the role you want - IP attorney, state attorney, JAG - and paste your resume. It helps you tell a powerful About story, nail your keywords and find alumni inside the firms you want.

Meet ProfileBot 4K
Free for every Ave Law student
"Make a dent in the universe."
Steve Jobs

I know you're in the slog of 1L year right now. But I can't wait to see all the amazing things you're going to do for the world in the years to come. ๐Ÿ™Œ

So much love to Jill, Deanna and Celestine, and to Allison, Sabrina and Aganze for sharing so generously. I'll be cheering you on every step of the way - see you on LinkedIn! ๐Ÿ’™

Jeremy