Anderson University ยท Center for Career Development ยท Oct 12, 2026

From Interview to Offer.

Your Trojan playbook for the first 5 minutes, the case question and the negotiation

Go Trojans! ๐Ÿ’› Huge love to Emily, Brandon and Julia for taking the hot seat (and the mic!), and to Quincie, Ellie, Kamara and every Trojan who jumped into the chat with answers, questions and a LOT of emoji love.

And the biggest thanks to Wendy and Jensen for bringing me to Anderson - and for wrangling the room, the mic and the volunteers like pros. Everything we covered is below, ready to use before your next interview. ๐Ÿ‘‡

The full session

Missed it - or want to watch Emily, Brandon and Julia again?

Here's the whole recording. Share it with any Trojan who couldn't make it.

Open the recording on YouTube

The big idea

Interviewers want the same thing you do: someone who can do the job AND someone they'd love to do it with.

We get so flustered by interviews and negotiation because we think the person across the table is out to get us. Nothing could be further from the truth. Nail both halves - competence and warmth - from the very first question all the way to the very last negotiation step.

Pop quiz #1

You're the big boss. Who would you rather work with?

C) Sandy. The chat was nearly unanimous, and Quincie nailed the why: she's super smart and really athletic - and she brings an outsider's perspective. Patrick is a nice guy. Mr. Krabs is extremely driven. But Sandy gives you both.

That's the duality every hiring manager is looking for: not just someone who can do the job, but someone you'd actually want to do the job with.

Research: Harvard Business Review, "Connect, Then Lead" (warmth + competence)

Tap any step to jump to its frameworks and copy-paste prompts.

1Win the First 5 Minutes

"Tell me about yourself" isn't an icebreaker. It's the whole ballgame.

Pop quiz #2

What share of interviewers say they make up their minds in the first five minutes?

C) A whopping 49%. Ellie, Robyn, Emily and Brady all got it, and Ellie nailed the why: first impressions. We're wired for fight or flight - can I trust this person or not? - and that instinct is alive and well in the modern Serengeti, the cubicle farm.

So we stress about behavioral questions, estimation questions, even the thank-you note... when so many interviews come down to the very first question.

A
7%
B
24%
C โœ“
49%
The laundry listHere's where I went to college, here's what I studied, my first job, my next job, blah blah blah. Safe because everyone does it - and deadly, because it's rambling (not competent) and robotic (not warm).
The PET answer"You've got my resume. Here's what you need to know: the couple of things that guide my life, a quick story that proves it, and why it matters for you." How I finally got offers at Apple and Google.

Emily's opener, live

An accounting major and junior who just transferred from Midlands Technical College with her associate's in business - and already has her eyes on a summer internship.

Her passion: running restaurants as a manager, she fell for the back end - labor hours, paychecks, scheduling. Her evidence: a year and a half as admin at a plumbing company, in a role built from the ground up, where she drove down outstanding invoices (yes, by nagging - professionally!). Her tie-in: firms want people who don't just get things done, but make them better.

Then she went live in a mock PwC interview and rocked it, nerves and all. The one push: tie it back to them even more - "I can speed up your AR." Every human wants to know what's in it for me. ๐Ÿ™Œ

Kamara asked
What if I don't have much experience to tie my evidence back to? Experience is experience is experience. When I was at LinkedIn, we surveyed recruiters across America about students' extracurriculars and volunteer work, and 40% said they value it on the same level as paid work. I was a kindergarten teacher trying to break into LinkedIn, and I still found the examples that linked. Work with Wendy and your career team to find your linkages - I guarantee you have them, and recruiters care.

The PET framework

PPassion. Open with the one or two things that genuinely drive you - your thesis statement.
EEvidence. One or two quick stories that prove it. Walk the talk.
TTie-in. It's not a me show, it's a you show. Why does this matter for their company and role?
  1. Remember the 3-to-5-paragraph essay from middle school: thesis, evidence, conclusion. Everyone can follow it - that's the competence.
  2. Start with what lights you up, not your timeline. That's the warmth.
  3. Keep it to one or two minutes. Human attention spans are short.
  4. Land on their problem: "Here's how I can help you..."

Emily asked: how do I get my resume to the top of the pile?

Almost every recruiter uses an ATS. It's not an evil AI out to crush your dreams - recruiters just have too many candidates and too little time, so they triage like EMTs. The ATS scores how well your resume matches the job description, and they spend their time on the Dans, not the Tylers. So find out what it's looking for:

PROMPT 1Find the keywords that matter
What are the top 10 keywords for this job description? [paste the job description]

In any job description, some keywords matter a lot more than others.

PROMPT 2Find your gaps
Which of those skills are missing from my resume? [upload your resume]

The same question the ATS is really trying to answer. Then don't just list them under Skills - weave them into your Experience section, showing how you used them as a student leader, volunteer or accounting major.

2Ace the Case

Companies want to know how you'd actually do the job. So don't spitball - get organized.

Pop quiz #3

What's Google most likely to ask candidates in 2026?

Trick question: none of the above! Colette, Courtney, Quincie and Kamara split across A, B and C. But when Google graded candidates on those crazy questions and then tracked their actual job performance, there was no correlation. Answering the blender question didn't make you a good Googler.

So brainteasers are getting pushed aside, and companies are getting down to brass tacks: here's the whole point of the job - how would you actually do it?

Source: Google's Laszlo Bock in The New York Times ("brainteasers are a complete waste of time")
AHow many golf balls fit inside a 747?
BHow many gas stations are in Manhattan?
CShrunk to the size of a nickel in a blender - how do you escape?
โœ“None of the above: how would you do the real job?

Brandon's ER, live

A nursing major with a simple goal: helping people. Wendy picked him, and the case was a doozy - a crowded, chaotic ER. How would you bring order to it?

Goal: patient satisfaction. Audience: the patients filling out those surveys. Pain: Brandon's best line of the day - the ER feels "alien-like". Unfamiliar, a sea of blue scrubs, nobody to talk to. Solution: clear communication and a safe space to ask questions. (Imagine if the ER gave you a DoorDash-style tracker - you know more about your tacos than your health!)

Brandon was in the hot seat, and yet he was the one on fire - en fuego. ๐Ÿ”ฅ The one push for every Trojan: always start with the North Star ("take satisfaction from 4 stars to 5"), and get specific. Specificity always crushes generality.

The GAPS framework

GGoals. What's the business trying to do? More revenue? Better AR? Higher patient satisfaction?
AAudience. Who are the customers or users you're serving?
PPain. What do they actually need? Where does it hurt?
SSolutions. Then, and only then, specific ideas aimed at that pain.
  1. Ask for time. "Can I take a moment to get organized?" As a hiring manager, I'm never offended - I'm flattered you think my question deserves a careful answer.
  2. Name the North Star metric first. It crystallizes everything else.
  3. Work backwards through audience and pain. That's the warmth: you care about the company and its customers, not just your own ideas.
  4. Finish with two or three specific solutions. That's the competence: logic and structure instead of running into a brick wall five seconds in.
๐ŸšซDon't go into spitball mode. That's what I used to do: nervous, throwing out answers left and right with no structure - and thinking only about what I cared about, not the user. It flunks both tests.
3Negotiate the Offer

You won the first 5 minutes. You aced the case. Now don't leave money on the table.

Pop quiz #4

Day one: the colleague with your exact job makes $50,000 more. How do you feel?

All the C's: absolutely furious and burning with incandescent rage! But here's the funny thing - we all say C, and then don't do anything about it. 58% of young professionals accepted their offer without negotiating.

And the kicker: of those who did negotiate, 87% got at least some of what they asked for.

58%didn't negotiate
87%who asked got something

Julia's AI agent, live

A neuroscience major, sophomore and international student from Brazil, who came down for the grand finale like it was a game show. Her read on the fear: early in our careers, we feel like we don't have a voice yet. That's imposter syndrome talking.

Here's the truth from the hiring manager's chair: when I make an offer, my reputation is tied to yours. I only make offers to people I believe in - and I'll do what it takes to get you, including negotiating. Companies are willing. You have to drive it.

So we built Julia her own Jerry Maguire in PartyRock, tested it on an AI-generated low-ball offer ($29K for a clinical research assistant - what I made 20 years ago!), and it came back with a fair range, leverage points and a script. Julia's verdict: "way more confident." ๐Ÿ’ช

๐Ÿ’กIt's not just about money. As Julia said: hours, job quality. Plus vacation days, hybrid vs. in-office, signing bonus, benefits - whatever matters to you.

Build your own negotiation agent

  1. Go to partyrock.aws - it's free - and create a new Flow (that's PartyRock's word for an app).
  2. Meet Whiskers, your army of software developers. Paste Prompt 3 and let Whiskers build it.
  3. Need a test case? Run Prompt 4 in any AI and paste the offer into your agent.
  4. Hit play and get your comparables, leverage points and script.
  5. Or skip the build entirely and use the one Julia made for every Trojan (Bonus 3 below).
PROMPT 3Your AI Jerry Maguire
I am a student at [Anderson University] and I want to build a negotiation agent that will take in a job offer from a firm that has given me an offer and will review it and help me negotiate. I want you to look through all the comparable salaries from other firms in the space at that same level, and then I want you to build out a specific analysis of where I can ask for either more money, more equity, more benefits, or anything else that's negotiable to give me a sense of where I can really push.

The company has all the information and the boss has all the power. This evens the odds.

PROMPT 4Stress-test it
Generate a really low-ball offer for a [neuroscience major] at Anderson University who's getting [her] first job right after graduation.

Challenge AI to come up with a really good test case, so you know your agent works before the real offer lands.

Comic book cover: Wendy Smith and Jensen Barker of Anderson University as The Dynamic Duo
For Wendy and Jensen, with love

Every Trojan needs a Dynamic Duo in their corner

Today, Wendy and Jensen ran the room, got the mic to every volunteer and even picked our ER hero, Brandon. That's what they do for you every single day at the Center for Career Development.

So here's the one action item I'd put above every prompt on this page: book time with them. Bring your PET story, your GAPS practice and your first offer - they've got your back from the first interview all the way to signing day. ๐Ÿ’›

For you, with love

3 big bonuses - all free, Trojans ๐ŸŽ

Courtesy of Wendy, Jensen and your career team. (Emily, Brandon and Julia: send me an email - your profile makeovers are on the way.)

Bonus 1

Connect with me

Questions after today - what did Jeremy say about interviews, what should I do with my LinkedIn? Always fair game. Send a request with a little note and I'll be in your corner of the ring for the rest of your career.

Connect on LinkedIn
thejobinsiders.com/connect
Bonus 2

Get a free profile makeover

Wanted one today but felt a little nervous putting yourself out there? Here's your second chance - straight from a LinkedIn insider.

Get my free makeover
thejobinsiders.com/profile
Bonus 3

Julia's Negotiation Coach

The exact agent we built live. Paste in your offer and your background, and it researches market comparables, builds your leverage points and drafts a ready-to-use negotiation script.

Try the Negotiation Coach
Free for every Trojan
ONE MORE THING โšก
The grand finale

InterviewBot 5000

My own AI tool, built for exactly this moment. Give it the specific job and your resume, and it interviews you one question after another - and after every answer, it gives you feedback on the two things that matter: your competence and your warmth. The perfect complement to the coaching you get from the Anderson team, yours forever.

Try InterviewBot 5000
Free for every Trojan, now and forever
"Whether you're an accountant, a nurse or a neuroscientist, you have the power at your fingertips to move mountains."
Closing today's session

I was an intern at Apple in the summer of 2011, sitting in the audience for what turned out to be Steve Jobs' last presentation. As sick and frail as he was, he still ended with his signature flourish - one more thing. So go do what Steve said: leave a big dent in the universe in everything you do next. ๐Ÿ™Œ

So much love to Wendy and Jensen, and to Emily, Brandon and Julia for being so brave. I can't wait to see you rock the world. Go Trojans! ๐Ÿ’›

Jeremy